Indian society particularly in urban cities has become more accepting of live-in relationships. However, cohabiting without marrying raises significant social and legal issues, one of which is when a relationship terminates and a woman initiates a rape accusation against a man.
What Is a Live-In Relationship Under The Indian Legal System?
A live-in relationship under the Indian legal system is not defined but it is such a situation in which two persons of the opposite sex live together as a couple without being officially married. Even the Supreme court and High court granted protection to such couples. The legal Indian system has no defined criteria or laws guiding live-in relationships, but in the past the Indian judiciary has accepted them through several judgments.
Need A Legal Advice
The internet is not a lawyer and neither are you. Talk to a real lawyer about your legal issue
Legal Basis:
- Article 21 of the Constitution guarantees personal liberty, including the choice of a spouse or right of individual to live with anyone they want.
- The 2005 Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (PWDVA) acknowledges “a relationship in the nature of marriage, but not considered a marriage (live in relationship) in section 2(f), and therefore confers the right to protection and maintenance to women in live-in relationships.
- In Lata Singh v. State of U.P. (2006): The Supreme court ruled that a couple may choose to live together without marriage because it is a fundamental right of each and every individual.
Thus, while not formally equivalent to marriage, live-in relationships are recognized in law for certain protections—especially for women.
Understanding Rape Under Indian Penal Code
Section 376 IPC/BNS 64 – Definition of Rape:
Under Section 376 IPC/BNS 64 a man is said to commit rape if he has sexual intercourse with a woman under any of the following conditions:
- Against her will.
- Without her consent.
- With her consent obtained by fear of death or hurt.
- With her consent when she is intoxicated or of unsound mind.
- With her consent when she believes he is her lawful husband.
- With or without her consent, if she is under 18 years of age.
If any of the above is proven, it constitutes the offence of rape under Indian law.
Can Rape Be Alleged After a Live-In Relationship Ends?
Generally, No, because when individuals enter into a live-in relationship, it is considered that they are agreeing to live with their partner with full concern and risk involved. But if someone was forced or blackmailed to live with their partner without her consent, then a case may be registered, but its success depends on several factors, particularly the nature of consent.
Courts evaluate:
- Whether consent was voluntary and informed.
- Whether it was induced by deception—especially false promises of marriage.
- Whether coercion, threat, or intoxication was involved.
If the sexual relationship was consensual during the live-in arrangement, the breakup alone does not make it rape. However, if it is proven that the woman agreed to sexual relations solely because she was misled into believing they would marry, it could be treated as rape under Section 90 IPC (consent obtained under misconception of fact).
Consent and Misconception of Fact: Legal Interpretation
Section 90 IPC/ 28 BNS: Consent given under a misconception of fact is not valid consent.
This provision becomes significant when a woman consents to sex based on a false promise of marriage. If the man never intended to marry her and only used the promise to obtain consent, the act may be considered rape.
However, courts also recognize that not every failed promise of marriage amounts to rape.
Landmark Judgments: How Courts View Such Cases
Uday v. State of Karnataka (2003)
- Facts: The prosecutrix alleged rape after the man didn’t marry her post live-in.
- Held: If the man genuinely intended to marry but later circumstances changed, it is not rape.
- Takeaway: Intention at the time of consent is key.
Dhruvaram Muralidhar Sonar v. State of Maharashtra (2018)
- Held: There is a clear distinction between rape and consensual sex in a relationship. False promise of marriage without any intention from the beginning can be rape.
“If it is established that the promise to marry was false and made only to satisfy lust, such consent is not free.”
Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra (2019)
- Held: Consent obtained under false promise of marriage can be rape, but there must be evidence that the promise was false and dishonest at the inception.
What Happens if a Woman Files a False Rape Case After Breakup?
Courts are increasingly cautious in handling such cases to prevent misuse of rape laws. Filing a false rape FIR is a criminal offence under Section 182 IPC (false information with intent to cause injury).
Also:
- Section 211 IPC/ 248 BNS: False charge of offence with intent to injure.
- Section 499/500 IPC/ 356 BNS: Defamation, if the false accusation harms reputation.
In many cases, men have been acquitted after courts found that the physical relationship was consensual and that the complaint arose only after the relationship ended.
Challenges in Distinguishing False Cases from Genuine Ones
Genuine Rape vs. Post-Breakup Grievance
Courts examine:
- The timing of the FIR (Was it filed soon after breakup?)
- The presence of supporting evidence (Chats, messages, witness testimonies)
- The woman’s understanding of the nature of the relationship
- The man’s intention and conduct during the relationship
A breakup followed by a rape complaint is not automatically treated as false or true. Courts adopt a fact-specific inquiry, which is case-dependent.
Supreme Court on Live-In Relationships and Rape Allegations
In various rulings, the apex court has emphasized that:
- Adults have the right to live together without marriage.
- A live-in relationship, by itself, does not imply marriage or betrayal.
- Filing rape charges for every failed relationship dilutes the seriousness of the offence.
Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, in a recent verdict, remarked: “Sexual relationships in modern society cannot be judged solely through the lens of morality but must be examined legally on facts of consent, deceit, and coercion.”
Preventive Measures Against Misuse of Rape Law
Proper Documentation in Live-in Relationships
Signing a cohabitation agreement can help establish mutual understanding and intent.
Legal Counselling for Couples
It’s advisable to seek legal advice before initiating or ending a live-in relationship.
Speedy Inquiry Mechanism
Courts often recommend a preliminary inquiry before FIR registration in sensitive cases, especially where past intimacy existed.
Awareness on Section 90 and Section 376 IPC
Both parties should be aware of what legally constitutes valid consent.
Conclusion
India’s evolving community impact has led to a rise in live-in relationships. While this gives freedom to partners, it also raises legal issues particularly concerning consent, breakup, and rape allegations. Filing a rape case after the end of a live-in relationship is legally possible, but it must satisfy the requirements under IPC Sections 376/64 BNS and 90 IPC/28 BNS. Courts assess these allegations based on intention, consent, and credibility of the complaint.
At the same time, misuse of rape laws to settle personal scores or to harass ex-partners is viewed seriously. False allegations harm not just the accused but also dilute the seriousness of genuine rape cases.
If you are facing such a situation—whether as an alleged victim or the accused—it is crucial to consult a criminal lawyer and proceed based on facts, law, and evidence.
One can talk to lawyers from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. Can rape be alleged after ending a live-in relationship?
Yes, but only if the consent was obtained through deceit, coercion, or false promise of marriage.
2. What if sex was consensual during live-in?
Consensual sex does not become rape just because the relationship ended, unless it involved deception.
3. Is false promise of marriage a ground for rape?
Yes, if it is proven that the promise was false and intended to mislead the woman into giving consent.
4. Can live-in relationships lead to maintenance claims?
Yes, under the Domestic Violence Act, women in live-in relationships can seek maintenance and protection.
Talk to a Lawyer