A franchise agreement is a legal contract placed between the franchisor (i.e., the business model or brand owner of the particular entity) and the franchisee (i.e., the candidate or entity desiring to carry out business under that brand). A franchise agreement states the nature of the arrangement, as well as the respective roles, rights, and obligations of the parties. A well drafted franchise agreement would not only be protective of the value of the brand to the franchisor, but would guarantee that franchisees can operate their businesses with transparency and fairness.
In India, there is no legislation on franchising. As franchises are contracts, a franchise agreement is governed under the general laws of contracts along with Intellectual Property Law, Consumer Protection Law as well as Competition Law. Franchising as a discipline can be very complex so it is vital to a franchise agreement carefully deals with certain important clauses to minimise uncertainty and risks of litigation.
Important Clauses in a Franchise Agreement
The clauses that you need to include in your franchise agreement are listed below with some case laws where relevant to clarify as to how the Indian Judiciary contemplates and interprets contractual clauses.
1. Grant of Franchise Rights: The Starting Point of Your Franchise
It is of utmost importance to define the rights being granted, and the nature of those rights and the scope for them. You should clearly state if the franchise is exclusive, non-exclusive or sole and what specific territory the franchisee could operate in when establishing the rights.
Key Elements:
- Territorial rights
- Scope of operations (products/services)
- Term of the agreement
Case: Jetking Infotrain Ltd. v. Milind M. Muley (2013): The Bombay High Court has stressed the importance of territory in franchise agreements, holding that a franchisee is obligated to carry on business only within the agreed territory. For example, as a franchisor, this clause restricts a franchisee from carrying out business outside the area that has been delineated to him and hence provides a check to the damage of your brand and operating model.
2. Franchise Fee and Payment Structure: Know the Money
There are no surprises with respect to payment. A franchise agreement must specify the franchise fee, royalties, marketing contributions and renewal fee.
Key Elements:
- Initial franchise fee
- Royalty payments (fixed or percentage-based)
- Marketing contributions
Case Study: Vimal Shah v. Young Entrepreneurs (2007): In a case of first-impression, the Gujarat High Court underscored the need for the franchisee to understand the rates of payment. If you’re a franchisee, confirm you understand exactly how and when you’ll be paying. In this case, the High Court found it was unfair to leave the rates of royalty payments unclear.
3. Intellectual Property Rights: Protecting Your Brand
Protecting the trademark of the franchisor, logos, and proprietary processes and methods is of prime importance for the franchisee. A franchise agreement, if well drafted, educates the franchisees on what the franchisor permits them to use and what they are forbidden to do.
Key Elements:
- Who owns the IP
- How the IP can be used
- Restrictions on misuse
Case Law: Coca-Cola Co. v. Bisleri International Pvt. Ltd. (2009) 41 PTC 100 (Del): It was stated; this well-recognized case in the Delhi High Court stated that intellectual property rights should be the subject of express stipulation in any given agreement. The decision here upheld trademarks and logos and prevented their unauthorized use.
4. Training and Support: setting up for success
A franchise must achieve successful training and ongoing support. The franchisor must give sufficient training, support, and continuous guidance for the success of the franchisee.
Key Elements:
- Type of training (initial and ongoing)
- Duration and frequency
- Associated costs
5. Obligations of the franchisor and franchisee: Who does what?
Every successful franchise will have clearly delineated responsibilities. Both franchisor and franchisee must be aware of their obligations to ensure that there is no misunderstanding in the future.
For the Franchisor:
- Supply of goods or services
- Marketing support
- Brand management
For the Franchisee:
- Adhering to brand standards
- Employee training
- Compliance with reports and audits
Case Study: Nirulas Corner House Pvt. Ltd. v. Nirula’s Franchisee (2007): Delhi High Court ruled that franchisees must ultimately obey brand standards. It was in breach of the contract in this case that the franchisee had not properly followed brand standards. For the franchisee, following brand guidelines is essentially a legal requirement and is not an option.
6. Operational Guidelines: Creating Consistency
These operational guidelines must be incorporated into franchise agreements to maintain brand integrity and ensure standardized practice from day-to-day by franchisees.
Key Elements:
- Menu or product specifications
- Hygiene and safety measures
- Staff attire and decorum
First-Hand Experience: After starting a franchise, the client realized how critical uniform operational standards are. Customers expect and appreciate consistency from one franchise to another, and this is what fosters brand loyalty.
7. Advertising and Marketing Obligations: Promoting the Brand Visibility
A strong advertising clause can ensure both parties are helping to promote the brand, while being consistent in how it does so.
Key Elements:
- Advertising fund contributions
- Local advertising responsibilities
- Approval process for independent marketing by the franchisee
Case Study: Subway Systems India v. Aditya Retail Pvt. Ltd. (2010): In the said decision, the court held there exists an authority vested on it under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution to interfere with such contracts and leave alone its position. A decision by the Delhi High Court has opined that a franchisee’s refusal to cooperate in the advertisement initiatives directed by the franchisor would dilute the brand equity. The franchisor and the franchisee should, therefore, maintain brand consistency by following the advertising guidelines laid down by the franchisor.
8. Term and Renewal: Planning for the Future
Your franchise agreement needs to clarify the initial term (always 5–10 years) and any renewal conditions.
Key Elements:
- Initial term (5–10 years)
- Renewal terms and conditions
9. Termination Clause: Knowing When to Quit
The termination clause becomes an essential part of a franchise agreement. The parties, franchisor and franchisee, should therefore understand how and under what circumstances they can be terminated. This clause should define:
- Grounds for termination (e.g., breach, insolvency)
- Notice period
- After termination obligations
Case Law: K.T. Plantations Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (2011) 9 SCC 1: The Supreme Court held that termination provisions should be fair and that there should be proportionality so that no party has the upper hand over the other party in a termination event.
10. Post-Termination Obligations: Tying up loose ends
A Franchisee must immediately refrain from using the Franchisor’s intellectual property, and brand name, and must also clear off any pending dues.
Key Elements:
- Stop using trademarks and signage
- Return confidential materials
- Settle financial dues
Case Law: The McDonald’s India Pvt. Ltd. v. Vikram Bakshi (2018), the Supreme Court held that as soon as a franchisee is terminated, it will be required to desist from operating under the brand; if it does not do so, it will be open to legal prosecution.
11. Non-Compete & Confidentiality: Protection of Trade Secrets
The non-compete clause provides that the franchisee may not open a competing business within a time period and territory or specific to the franchise network they were a part of once the agreement is terminated. Further, the confidentiality clause forbids the ex-franchisee from misusing the franchisor’s trade secrets.
Legal Position: In India, the post-termination non-compete clause should not fall foul of the legality test in order to be enforceable.
12. Dispute Resolution Clause: Settling Disputes in a Timely Manner
Should the situations raising conflicts arise, the dispute resolution clause guarantees that both parties have already agreed on a road to be taken when the conflict surface, including whether these disputes will be taken up for arbitration or litigation.
13. Force Majeure: what happens ‘when the unexpected occurs’
A force majeure clause will free parties of liability when an unforeseen event, often a natural disaster, prevents one or both of them from carrying out their obligations.
14. Audit and Inspect Rights: making it transparent
Franchisors will require or request a right of inspection of premises or audit financial records to confirm that business standards are implemented and maintained.
15. Amendments and Entire Agreement: making it formal
This document will clearly state that any amendments must be in writing and signed by the parties who are also signatories to the current franchise agreement.
Conclusion
A franchise agreement is more than just a legal document: it describes the whole architecture for an essential business partnership. Utilizing clear and enforceable clauses that address everything from intellectual property to dispute resolutions, a franchisor, or a franchisee has a mechanism to avoid expensive mistakes, and build a viable business.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. What is the length of a franchise agreement?
Franchise agreements generally have a duration of 5 to 10 years, with extensions to rely on the franchisee’s continuing ability to comply with the company’s standards and system, as well as to comply with the requirements of the franchise agreement. The agreement will spell out any renewal terms, as well as whether any fees or conditions will change with the renewal.
2. Can a franchisee work outside the agreed territory?
No, the franchise contract usually includes territorial rights. The contract gives the franchisee a specific geographical area to operate in. Operating outside the assigned territory without consent assumes the franchisee has breached the contract and could face legal action.
Talk to a Lawyer