What Are The Major Gst Disputes And How To Resolve Them?

People sometimes misuse the benefits of GST. Some taxpayers are denying input tax credit, disallowing refunds, not sticking to procedural matters, creating transitional issues, demanding tax for wrong reasons, or even cancelling registrations with no justification.

Whether these conflicts can be treated administratively or whether they should be settled by bodies such as the GST Appellate Tribunal (“GSTAT”), or High Courts; and a further step of judicial interventions by the Supreme Court. 

This article discusses the various forms of GST disputes, remedies for such disputes, landmark judgments shaping GST law, and practical tips from actual cases. 

Common GST Disputes That Can Land You in Trouble and How to Solve Them?

1. ITC Denials for Minor Invoice Errors

A client importing medical devices lost ₹5.65 crore ITC because of an incorrect GSTIN on invoices. We relied on B. Braun Medical India Pvt. Ltd. (Delhi HC, 2025) to prove the transaction was genuine. The HC ordered ITC restoration, saving the client from a massive cash crunch.

2. Refund Restrictions Under Inverted Duty Structure

When a manufacturing client claimed refunds on service inputs, we had to explain the Supreme Court’s ruling in VKC Footsteps (2021) that only goods qualify under Section 54(3). We restructured procurement to avoid future loss.

3. Clerical Mistakes in GST Returns

In Aberdare Technologies (SC, 2025), the Court confirmed that mistakes in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B can be corrected. We used this precedent to get an ITC denial reversed for a client who had mismatched figures in March returns.

4. E-Credit Ledger Blocked Without Reason

One trader’s ITC was blocked for six months without explanation. Referring to Goyal Iron & Steel Traders (Delhi HC), we secured a reasoned order requirement and the credit was unblocked.

5. GST Orders Served Only on Portal

A real estate client missed a filing deadline because the order was only uploaded online. Using Pandidorai Sethupathi Raja (Madras HC), we proved service was valid but argued for delay condonation, and won.

Quick Remedies Before a Dispute Escalates

Administrative Actions You Can Take Today

• File DRC-03 to voluntarily correct small tax shortfalls and avoid penalties.
• Rectify orders under Section 161 within 3 months for minor errors.
• Demand a hearing under Section 75(4) before any adverse order, as we did for Mahaveer Trading Co., where the HC quashed an ex-parte decision.

Appeal Pathways You Should Not Miss

• First Appeal (FAA): File GST APL-01 within 3 months with 10% pre-deposit.
• GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT): Fully operational by March 2025.
• High Court Writs: When GSTAT is not functioning or natural justice is denied.
• Supreme Court SLPs: For rulings with nationwide impact.

Landmark Judgments That Can Save You Lakhs

Case	What It Means for You
B. Braun Medical India	ITC cannot be denied for technical invoice errors.
Aberdare Technologies	You can fix GST return errors and reclaim ITC.
Goyal Iron & Steel Traders	ITC blocking requires a valid reasoned order.
Varshan Enterprises	Refunds possible even beyond Section 54 in unjust enrichment cases.
SC ITC Pre-Deposit Ruling (2025)	Pay your GST appeal pre-deposit from the credit ledger, not cash.

Strategies Recommended to Every GST Client

• Maintain accurate records including invoices, e-way bills, and payment proofs.
• Respond to show-cause notices with legal precedents and evidence.
• Use ITC for appeal pre-deposit to avoid cash flow problems.
• File writ petitions when procedural fairness is violated.
• Shift liability to defaulting suppliers when possible, using the Bhumi Associate precedent.

First-Hand Experience: Lessons from the Courtroom

• Case 1: ITC Mismatch Victory: A textile exporter faced ₹1.8 crore ITC denial over a GSTR-2A mismatch. The law firm produced supplier payment proofs and cited Bhumi Associate. The HC directed the department to recover from the supplier instead.
• Case 2: Refund After Three Years: A client’s transitional credit refund claim was rejected as time-barred. Using Star India Pvt. Ltd. (2025), we got the refund sanctioned three years after the original application.
• Case 3: Pre-Deposit Relief: A construction company saved ₹72 lakh in cash by paying its GST appeal pre-deposit from the E-credit ledger, following the Supreme Court’s May 2025 ruling.

Conclusion 

In India, giving rise to quite complex GST disputes, nevertheless, they can be overcome. Documentation of transactions, applying strategic approaches, and citing the suitable case laws can protect your business from unlawful tax demands. From experience, sooner intervention and a fine-tuned legal strategy can save a lot of money and time spent in litigation. 

One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.

FAQs

1. How can I challenge an ITC denial under GST?

You can reply to the show-cause notice with supporting invoices, payment proofs, and relevant case law precedents. If the order is adverse, you may file an appeal with the First Appellate Authority and, if required, escalate to the GST Appellate Tribunal or High Court.

2. Can I use my ITC balance for the GST appeal pre-deposit?

Yes. As per the Supreme Court’s May 2025 ruling, taxpayers can use their E-credit ledger balance to pay the mandatory 10% pre-deposit for filing GST appeals, reducing cash flow strain.

3. What is Rule 86A and when can my E-credit ledger be blocked?

Rule 86A allows blocking of ITC if authorities suspect fraud or ineligible credit claims. However, as per Delhi High Court rulings, blocking must be supported by a reasoned order and cannot be done automatically.