Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) protect creativity and innovation. Where IP is infringed, the challenge is enforcing those rights in courts. In India, cases can take years to reach a conclusion, which reduces the utility of IPRs. Trademarks, patents, and copyrights are time-sensitive, and if there is a delay in protection, then the protection is lost.
This is where Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) offers expedient, cost-effective, and business-like options through arbitration, mediation, conciliation, and negotiated settlement. Courts in India have even suggested arbitration to manage the backlog of cases. This article presents the most effect legal remedies and dispute resolution procedures in IPR in India, and references some key judgments and practical scenarios.
Why Do Intellectual Property Disputes Need Quick Resolution?
In experience advising clients on trademark and copyright disputes, the biggest complaint is delay. Creators often say, “By the time the injunction comes, the damage is already done.”
The Supreme Court itself has recognized this:
- In Shree Vardhman Rice (2009), it directed IPR cases to be wrapped up within four months.
- In Bajaj Auto (2009), it said slow litigation defeats the very purpose of protection.
If you are a startup, artist, or business owner, the real risk is that your innovation loses value while waiting for a judgment. This is why ADR matters.
What Are the Practical Options for IPR Dispute Resolution Beyond Courts?
1. Arbitration: Is It the Best Option for Licensing Disputes?
From working with IT and pharma companies, it is seen that arbitration clauses in licensing agreements save months of court battles.
- Governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
- Allows appointment of industry experts as arbitrators.
- Keeps business negotiations confidential.
Example: A client in the software industry avoided public courtroom exposure of their source code by opting for arbitration.
2. Mediation: Can It Save Business Relationships in IP Conflicts?
The law firm once mediated a dispute between two music labels over royalty distribution. Instead of years in court, they settled in weeks, and still work together.
- Courts encourage mediation under Section 89 CPC.
- Useful where parties want to continue partnerships.
- Delhi HC’s Bawa Masala case (2019) even introduced early neutral evaluation.
For businesses, mediation means less hostility and more collaboration.
3. Conciliation and Settlement: When Should You Choose This Path?
Conciliation works well when both parties are willing to compromise. The law firm advised startups who resolved brand name disputes quickly through conciliation, avoiding PR damage.
- Conciliator plays an active role in suggesting solutions.
- Saves costs and preserves goodwill.
Are All Intellectual Property Disputes Arbitrable in India?
This is one of the most common client questions I hear: “Can we arbitrate our IP dispute instead of going to court?”
The short answer: Yes, but with limits.
- Contractual disputes (licensing, royalties): Arbitrable.
- Validity of IP rights (like whether a patent is valid): Must go to court.
Example: In Eros International (2016), the Bombay HC confirmed that most commercial IPR disputes are arbitrable.
How Do Patents, Trademarks, and Copyrights Work with ADR?
Patent Disputes:
- Complex and technical, which makes ADR effective since arbitrators with scientific expertise can be appointed.
- Section 103, Patents Act, 1970 allows arbitration in licensing issues.
In one pharma licensing case the law firm advised on, arbitration saved the client from disclosing confidential R&D data in open court.
Trademark Disputes:
- Most disputes are between parties: infringement, licensing, passing off.
- Perfect for arbitration or mediation.
- Domain name disputes (UDRP, INDRP) are already handled by arbitration.
If your domain is misused, you don’t need to wait for years in court. Arbitration under INDRP can resolve it in months.
Copyright Disputes:
- Common in music, film, and publishing.
- Usually about royalties and ownership, which are contractual.
- ADR helps avoid reputational damage.
It is seen that the film producers resolve music rights disputes through mediation in under three months, saving both their film release and business relationships.
What Challenges Should You Expect in ADR for IPR?
Even though ADR is powerful, there are some practical hurdles:
- Public Policy: Courts can set aside awards against public interest (ONGC v. Saw Pipes, 2003).
- Validity of IP Rights: Questions like “Is this patent valid?” still go to court.
- Territorial Enforcement: IP rights are country-specific, so cross-border disputes need careful drafting of arbitration clauses.
First-hand note: Clients often assume “arbitration = global remedy.” That’s not true. Always plan for enforcement in every jurisdiction where your IP matters.
What Is the Way Forward for IPR Disputes in India?
The shift is clear; courts want businesses to use ADR.
- Delhi HC promotes early neutral evaluation.
- Bombay HC recognizes arbitrability of IPR contracts.
For clients, this means:
- Speed: Avoid endless adjournments.
- Confidentiality: Keep trade secrets safe.
- Expertise: Appoint arbitrators with sector knowledge.
- Relationships: Resolve without burning bridges.
From practice, the clients most satisfied with outcomes are those who chose ADR first instead of waiting for years in litigation.
Conclusion: Should You Choose ADR for Your IPR Dispute?
Yes, in most cases. If your dispute is contractual (licensing, royalties, ownership issues), ADR is faster, confidential, and effective.
Courts will still handle validity questions, but for most business disputes, ADR is your best bet. Broadening the use of ADR will not only reduce judicial backlog but also protect innovation and foreign investors in India. If your IP is infringed, consult a lawyer about adding an ADR clause into your commercial contracts, or move your ongoing litigation to mediation. You may save years of time.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. What are the most applicable remedies if my intellectual property is infringed in India?
You may apply for an injunction restraining your infringer, seek damages or royalties, an order for delivery-up of infringing goods, and propose ADR as a faster resolution.
2. Is it possible for domain name disputes to be adjudicated outside of court?
It is. The INDRP (Indian Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy) provides a process for arbitrating domain name disputes outside of court, in a non-heavy litigation manner.
3. Is mediation binding in IPR disputes?
It isn’t; mediation is not binding. However, once the parties agree to a settlement and sign a settlement agreement, it becomes legally enforceable in court.
Talk to a Lawyer