What Is Muslim Women Protection Of Rights On Marriage Act, 2019?

In a gender justice initiative, the Indian Parliament passed the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019, commonly known as Triple Talaq Act. The practice of instant triple talaq (Talaq-e-Biddat) was criminalized by this Act where a Muslim man could divorce his wife immediately by uttering the word “talaq” thrice. The Act aims to protect Muslim women under constitutional provisions, especially those relating to equality, dignity, and non-discrimination. 

Before the Law: When “Talaq” Meant Losing Everything Overnight

From time immemorial till social media age, this practice of ‘instant talaq’ enabled the Muslim husband to divorce his wife by simply saying the word ‘talaq’ thrice. Women like Nagma from Bhopal shared how her husband sent a voice note at 1 AM with the triple talaq. The next morning, she and her two children were locked out of their own house. Despite global Islamic rejection of this practice, Indian Muslim women had little legal protection, until now.

The Shayara Bano Case

Shayara Bano, a woman being triple-talaq’ed, had rushed to the courts in 2017. Her bravery went into the making of the landmark case, Shayara Bano v. Union of India, (2017). 

The Supreme Court observed:

• “Triple Talaq is arbitrary and violates Article 14 of the Indian Constitution.” 
• But the Court didn’t make it a crime. That came later, through the 2019 legislation.

What the Triple Talaq Act Really Does?

This law wasn’t just about making a statement; it changed the legal game for Muslim women:

• Instant talaq is now illegal.
• Men can be jailed for up to 3 years for pronouncing triple talaq.
• Women are entitled to maintenance.
• Mothers can get custody of minor children.
• The law applies whether talaq is spoken, written, or sent digitally.

Real Power, Real Protection: Maintenance and Custody Rights

Take the case of Amina, a school teacher from Lucknow. Her husband divorced her via WhatsApp. With no income and a young son, she was devastated. Under this Act, the court ordered her ex-husband to pay monthly maintenance and granted her custody.

This wasn’t possible before 2019. The Act legally ensures:

• Financial subsistence allowance.
• Custody of minor children, with Magistrate approval.
• A say in bail decisions, the wife must be heard before bail is granted.

Yes, it’s a Crime Now: What Happens to the Husband?

• The offence is cognizable- police can arrest without a warrant.
• It is non-bailable, but compoundable. The wife can choose to forgive.
• Bail is only granted after hearing the wife’s side.

India Joins the Global Movement: What Other Countries Do

India was late to the reform. However, it chose not to criminalize it. Policymakers in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Egypt, and Tunisia, however, were having none of it.

• Pakistan: Banned in compliance with the Muslim Family Law Ordinance, 1961 
• Bangladesh: Triple talaq is prohibited
• Egypt: Triple talaq is only valid if registered in court
• Tunisia: There is authority in the hands of the court to end a marriage

The 2019 Act helped India align with global Islamic legal reform.

Is the Act Fair? What Critics Say

While many women call the law empowering, others raise concerns:

• It criminalizes a civil issue.
• The law may be misused by estranged spouses.
• There’s no provision for reconciliation before criminal action.
• Being non-bailable could lead to harassment.

Some men’s rights groups have called for amendments, but the law has been upheld in courts so far.

Landmark Cases After the Law Came into Force

• Reshma v. State of U.P. (2020): Talaq over WhatsApp was held punishable by the court.
• Mohd. Javed v. State of Maharashtra (2021): The Bombay High Court ruled that even email and phone-based talaq could be prosecuted under the Act.
• Afsana Bano v. Union of India (2022): The Supreme Court refused to stay the law, upholding Parliament’s authority to legislate.

What the Numbers Say: Has the Law Worked?

According to government reports (2020-2023):

• Triple talaq cases dropped sharply after 2019.
• Over 300 arrests were made under the Act.
• From the year 2022, there have been no reported cases in various states.
• The data shows a deterrent effect, not just punishment, but prevention.

Politics and Parliament: What Happened During the Debate

The Bill passed in:

• Lok Sabha: July 25, 2019
• Rajya Sabha: July 30, 2019

Opposition parties raised concerns over criminalizing a personal matter. Supporters said this was about real empowerment, not politics.

Are There Still Legal Challenges?

Yes, several petitions argue:

• Triple talaq is a religious matter, not criminal.
• Making it non-bailable goes too far.

But the Supreme Court hasn’t struck it down and maintains that Parliament acted within its rights.

Conclusion: A Law That Gave Voice to the Silenced

The Triple Talaq Act has done what generations of silent suffering could not. Women across India, especially in rural and conservative areas, now have legal tools to fight back.

It’s not a perfect law. But it’s a powerful beginning.

Key Things to Remember (Triple Talaq Law India)

• Triple talaq is illegal and punishable by law.
• Muslim women can claim maintenance and child custody.
• The offense is compoundable with the wife’s consent but it is not subject to bail.
• Courts have upheld the Act’s constitutional validity.

One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.

FAQs

1. Can a woman file an FIR immediately after receiving triple talaq?

Yes. Under the 2019 Act, triple talaq is a cognizable offence. The woman can directly approach the police and register an FIR without prior court approval.

2. Is triple talaq valid if the husband later claims he said it in anger or jokingly?

No. The law declares any form of instant triple talaq, regardless of intent, as void and punishable. Courts do not recognize such talaq as valid under the 2019 Act.

3. Can the wife withdraw the case after filing under the Triple Talaq Act?

Yes. The offence is compoundable under the law, meaning the wife can choose to withdraw the case with the Magistrate’s permission.