Health insurance provides coverage for the medical and hospitalization expenses incurred by an insured person. However, an insurer may refuse to honor a claim completely or may pay only part of the amount claimed. This usually happens because of certain exclusions, waiting periods, pre-existing diseases, or non-disclosure of facts, or even incomplete documents or policy provisions. But all this does not mean that one has no chance to win the dispute in front of the insurer. A policyholder may study the policy, understand the reasons for the refusal, register grievances, and take legal steps to protect his rights.
Why Health Insurance Claims Get Rejected or Reduced
Insurance claims may be rejected or reduced for several reasons. Some reasons may be legitimate under the terms of the policy, while others may be capable of being challenged depending upon the facts and circumstances.
Common reasons include:
- Claim falling under an express policy exclusion;
- Waiting period not being completed;
- Alleged non-disclosure of material medical information;
- Pre-existing disease exclusion or limitation;
- Submission of incomplete or incorrect documents;
- Treatment not being covered under the policy;
- Non-medical or inadmissible expenses;
- Violation of policy conditions;
- Claim being submitted after the prescribed period without sufficient explanation; or
Dispute regarding the necessity or nature of treatment.
A policyholder should therefore carefully examine the insurer’s written claim decision rather than assuming that every deduction or rejection is final.
What Does Health Insurance Claim Rejection Mean?
Health insurance claim rejection means that insurer has refused to pay claim, either completely or in the circumstances where insurer considers claim outside the scope of the policy coverage.
The insurer should communicate the reason for the rejection to the policyholder. A policyholder should examine whether stated reason is actually supported by:
- The terms and conditions of the insurance policy;
- The proposal form and declarations;
- Medical records;
- Hospital bills and treatment documents;
- Previous correspondence with the insurer; and
- Applicable regulatory requirements.
In case the denial is due to a policy exclusion, the relevant policy should be checked to see if it applies to that treatment or medical condition being dealt with.
Simply making reference to an overarching exclusion without any explanation could challenge the rationale for the rejection.
What Does Reduced Claim Settlement Mean?
When it comes to claim settlements, reduced claim settlements refer to situations when the insurer agrees to the claim of the insured but compensates a lower amount than what was claimed.
For instance, a policyholder may claim an amount of ₹5 lakhs but receive an approval of ₹3 lakh from the insurers after deductions.
The reduction may arise due to:
- Policy sub-limits;
- Deductibles or co-payment;
- Non-payable expenses;
- Room-rent restrictions;
- Limits applicable to particular treatments;
- Insufficient supporting documents; or
- Other terms and conditions of the policy.
The insured party should ask for a descriptive settlement invoice which highlights the validity for each deduction. If there is a difference in deductions from the conditions of the policy or there are other disputes, the insured party can contest such deducted amounts using the mechanisms for grievances provided by the insurance company or otherwise.
Common Reasons for Claim Rejection
The Insurance companies may reject the health insurance claims on different grounds. Some of the commonly cited reasons include:
1. Non-Disclosure of Medical Information
It could be the case that an insurance company claims that the client has failed to reveal a past medical problem or critical facts when getting insurance coverage. This accusation from the insurance company ought to be verified against the proposal, medical history, terms of the insurance policy and circumstances of the alleged withholding.
2. Pre-Existing Disease
Two types of conditions are dealt within the insurance plans: medical conditions with an initial waiting period and the conditions that are not covered due to exceptions in the policy. It is essential that the patient checked whether the particular problem fits the definition of the problem, and therefore he/she should make sure that the insurance plan under which the case is discussed establishes waiting periods.
3. Policy Exclusion
A certain type of treatment will not be covered under the rules of the contract. It is the insurance company that has to provide the name of the exclusion related to the particular case.
4. Incomplete Documentation
Claims may sometimes get delayed or rejected because the required documents have not been submitted. The policyholders should promptly provide the documents requested by the insurer and retain the proof of submission.
5. Waiting Period
Certain treatments and the diseases may be subject to the waiting periods. The policyholder should check the policy schedule and the applicable terms before challenging rejection on this particular ground.
6. Non-Payable Expenses
The insurer may then deduct certain expenses that are not at all covered under the policy. The policyholder should obtain the itemized deduction statement and verify deductions against policy.
When Can a Policyholder Challenge Claim Rejection?
A policyholder may consider challenging the insurer’s decision when:
- The rejection reason is inconsistent with the policy terms;
- The insurer has not provided a clear or adequate explanation;
- The insurer has applied an exclusion that does not appear relevant;
- The claim has been reduced without proper calculation;
- Necessary documents were submitted but were allegedly ignored;
- The insurer has relied upon incorrect or incomplete facts;
- There is a dispute concerning pre-existing disease or disclosure; or
- The claim has been improperly delayed or repudiated.
The strength of the challenge depends upon the policy wording, medical evidence, correspondence, claim documents, and circumstances of the case.
Legal Framework Governing Health Insurance Claims
The insurance contract and the relevant insurance laws, regulations, terms, and conditions, along with the directions given by the IRDAI, apply to the health insurance claims made in India.
There are claims settlement and grievance redressal provisions that insurance companies must adhere to.
A policyholder generally has the right to:
- Receive policy documents and relevant terms;
- Receive information regarding claim requirements;
- Know the reason for claim rejection or deduction;
- Submit documents and explanations supporting the claim;
- Raise a grievance with the insurer;
- Approach the Insurance Ombudsman where applicable; and
- Seek appropriate legal remedies before the competent consumer or judicial forum.
The exact remedy depends upon the nature of the dispute, amount involved, policy terms, as well as the applicable law.
What Should You Do After Claim Rejection or Reduction?
The policyholder should avoid immediately accepting rejection or the reduced settlement without examining reasons.
The following steps may be taken:
Step 1: Obtain written rejection or the settlement letter.
Do not rely only on the verbal communication from the hospital desk, third-party administrator, or the insurer.
Step 2: Read relevant policy clauses.
Identify exclusion, limitation, waiting period, deductible, or the condition relied upon by the insurer.
Step 3: Collect the medical documents.
Preserve all the prescriptions, diagnostic reports, discharge summaries, hospital bills, investigation reports, as well as any other relevant records.
Step 4: Ask for itemized deduction statements.
If at all the claim has been partially settled, then ask the insurer to explain each and every deduction.
Step 5: Raise the formal grievance.
Submit written representation to the insurer’s grievance redressal mechanism as well as retain the acknowledgment.
Step 6: Escalate dispute wherever necessary.
If grievance is not at all satisfactorily resolved, then the policyholder may consider Insurance Ombudsman, consumer commission, or any other appropriate legal remedy.
Can You Approach the Insurance Ombudsman?
Yes, in eligible cases, a policyholder can contact the Insurance Ombudsman after observing the grievance process prescribed by the insurer.
The Insurance Ombudsman mechanism provides a specialized avenue for resolving certain disputes related to insurance outside of the need for the policyholder to pursue lengthy court proceedings immediately.
A policyholder should maintain the copies of:
- The insurance policy;
- Claim form;
- Rejection or settlement letter;
- Medical records;
- Bills and receipts;
- Communications with the insurer; and
- Grievance correspondence.
The applicability of the Ombudsman mechanism depends upon the nature of the dispute and prescribed conditions and limits.
Can You Approach the Consumer Commission?
In appropriate cases, a policyholder may approach the consumer commission alleging deficiency in service or other legally sustainable grounds.
For example, where an insurer has improperly repudiated a genuine claim, made unjustified deductions, or failed to deal with the claim in accordance with the policy and applicable requirements, the policyholder may consider seeking relief through the consumer dispute redressal mechanism.
Depending upon the facts, the policyholder may seek:
- Payment of the admissible claim amount;
- Refund of unjustified deductions;
- Interest for delayed payment, where legally justified;
- Compensation for established loss or deficiency; and
- Costs or other appropriate relief.
The appropriate forum and procedure should be determined according to the applicable law and facts of the case.
Documents Required to Challenge an Insurance Claim Decision
A strong documentary record is extremely important in an insurance dispute.
- The policyholder should preserve:
- Insurance policy and policy schedule;
- Proposal form and declarations;
- Claim form;
- Claim rejection or settlement letter;
- Hospital admission and discharge records;
- Medical reports and prescriptions;
- Hospital bills and payment receipts;
- Diagnostic reports;
- TPA communications;
- Emails, letters, and grievance correspondence;
- Identity and bank documents relevant to the claim; and
- Any other document relied upon by the insurer.
The policyholder should also maintain a chronological record of the claim process.
Rights of Policyholders During Claim Settlement
A policyholder does not lose legal rights merely because an insurance company has rejected or reduced a claim.
Policyholders are entitled to:
- Receive clear information regarding claim requirements;
- Know the reasons for rejection or deduction;
- Submit relevant supporting documents;
- Raise grievances against claim decisions;
- Obtain acknowledgment of representations;
- Challenge an incorrect or unjustified claim decision; and
- Seek appropriate legal remedies wherever necessary.
At the same time, the policyholders should provide the truthful information, comply with the reasonable policy requirements, as well as preserve all relevant records.
Practical Tips to Avoid Claim Rejection
Policyholders can reduce possibility of the disputes by taking following precautions:
Read policy terms before purchasing the insurance.
- Understand the waiting periods and the exclusions.
- Disclose material medical information accurately while purchasing the policy.
- Keep copies of the proposal form and policy documents.
- Inform the insurer or TPA as required under the policy.
- Submit complete medical and billing documents.
- Obtain written communication regarding claim decisions.
- Ask for the itemized explanation of the deductions.
- Do not rely solely on verbal assurances.
- Keep the copies of each and every email, letter, bill, as well as the acknowledgment.
- Raise the grievances promptly after the adverse decision.
- Seek for legal advice where the claim involves substantial amounts or complex contractual issues.
Proper documentation and timely action can significantly improve the ability of a policyholder to contest an unjustified claim decision.
A declined health insurance claim or a claim with a lower amount can be a reason for financial difficulty, but people can still appeal. Policyholders need to read their policy documents, understand why their claim was rejected, keep their medical and financial records, and file a formal complaint. If the issues are not resolved, they can make a complaint at the Insurance Ombudsman or consumer forums.
How Lead India Can Help?
- Provide legal guidance regarding rejected, repudiated, or partially settled health insurance claims.
- Assist in examining insurance policies, exclusions, waiting periods, and claim documents.
- Help prepare a representation or legal notice challenging an unjustified claim rejection or deduction.
- Assist policyholders in pursuing appropriate grievance redressal mechanisms.
- Provide assistance in insurance disputes before appropriate consumer or other legal forums.
- Help to evaluate the medical records, claim correspondence, as well as the settlement statements to identify the potential grounds for challenge.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. Can I challenge the rejected health insurance claim?
Yes. A policyholder may challenge a rejected claim where there are valid grounds to dispute the insurer’s decision. The first step is generally to obtain the written rejection reason and examine it against the policy terms and supporting documents.
2. What should I do if at all the insurance company pays only the part of my claim?
Ask the insurer for the itemized settlement statement explaining each and every deduction. If deductions are inconsistent with policy or otherwise appear fully unjustified, then you can raise the formal grievance and pursue for further remedies where appropriate.
3. Can I approach the Insurance Ombudsman for the health insurance dispute?
In eligible cases, yes. The Insurance Ombudsman provides a mechanism for resolving certain insurance disputes, subject to the applicable requirements and conditions.
4. Can I file a consumer case against an insurance company?
Yes, in appropriate cases, a policyholder may approach the competent consumer commission alleging deficiency in service or other legally sustainable grounds. The maintainability and appropriate forum depend upon the facts and applicable law.
5. Does claim rejection mean that I have no legal remedy?
No. A claim rejection is an insurer’s decision and does not by itself eliminate the policyholder’s right to challenge the decision through available grievance or legal mechanisms.


Talk to a Lawyer