In the modern competitive marketplace, a business’s trademark transcends mere name or logo; it is its brand identity, and your consumers’ trust in you. If someone misappropriates your mark, your business can cause itself loss, both in revenue and reputation. This is why trademark registration under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 is more than a legal formality; it is a business necessity.
When you register your trademark, you obtain enforcement rights; you receive exclusivity to use your mark, and to cease others using it. So, what is infringement, and what can you do by way of legal remedies in India?
What Counts as Trademark Infringement in India?
Trademark infringement occurs where:
- Someone uses a mark that is identical, or confusingly similar to yours that confuses consumers.
- A supplier or distributor knowingly helps in selling counterfeit goods.
- Even without registration, your goodwill is misused (called “passing off”).
Example from practice: An FMCG company found counterfeit soaps on local shelves. Even though packaging was slightly different, the logo placement misled rural consumers. The court immediately granted an injunction under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
Legal Framework That Protects Your Brand
Trade Marks Act, 1999 – Your Shield in Court
This Act gives businesses exclusive rights to their registered marks.
Key features include:
- Register early: Choose a unique mark and apply.
- Examination and Publication: The Registry will determine as to if there is conflict with a third party.
- Registration: If no opposition, the Registry will issue a certificate which is valid for a period of 10 years, and can be renewed indefinitely.
Practical tip: Many businesses delay registration thinking it’s costly. In reality, litigation costs of fighting infringement without registration are much higher.
Trade Marks Rules, 2017 – Faster and Digital
These rules made the process quicker with e-filing and expedited examination. For one of the startup clients, opting for expedited examination meant getting registration in under 8 months, instead of waiting over 2 years.
Different Types of Infringement You Should Watch For
Direct Infringement
- When someone uses a mark almost identical to yours.
- Example: A Noida electronics shop using “Applle” for mobile phones.
Indirect Infringement
- When third parties help in infringement knowingly.
- Example: Printers supplying counterfeit packaging for a popular biscuit brand.
Passing Off
- Even without registration, businesses with goodwill can protect themselves.
- Example: A bakery in Lucknow selling cola as “Pepsy.”
Remedies and Penalties: What Courts Can Do for You?
Civil Remedies You Can Seek:
- Injunctions: Quick orders stopping misuse. In one case, our client got interim relief in just 2 weeks.
- Damages: Courts award compensation for lost business.
- Destruction of Goods: Fake stock is seized and destroyed.
- Legal Costs: Courts can award reimbursement of litigation expenses.
Criminal Penalties:
Under Sections 103-105 of the Act:
- Jail up to 3 years.
- Fine up to ₹2,00,000.
- Seizure of counterfeit goods.
Practical note: Criminal raids are effective against large counterfeit markets. We have successfully executed raids in Delhi’s Sadar Bazaar with police assistance.
Landmark Cases That Changed Trademark Law
- N.R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation (1996): Indian courts protected the brand of a global company even in the absence of local usage.
- Coca-Cola v. Bisleri International (2009): A seller cannot re-register the assignment rights.
- Yahoo! Inc. v. Akash Arora (1999): This case expanded protection to the arena of domain names, which became relevant in the digital age.
- Amul v. Amul Restaurant (2008): It was held that no business can avail itself of an advantage attached to a famous trade mark, even if the businesses are otherwise unrelated.
- Cadila Healthcare v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals (2001): Deceptive similarity standard was established, which is still applied by courts today.
How to Stay Ahead: Proactive Steps Businesses Must Take
- Register early: Don’t wait until the trademark is famous before you register.
- Use watch programs: To identify potential infringers by checking the Trademark Journal and online.
- Send cease-and-desist notices: Often, it stops the product or service.
- Making sure you protect the brand everywhere: Register through the as Madrid Protocol.
- Train your employees and distributors: Educate all on the way they are expected to use the brand.
- Monitor online platforms: Be diligent monitoring Amazon, Flipkart, Instagram for false advertising or product listings.
Real story: There was a client in the fashion industry who showed us pictures of fake Instagram shops that were selling products in this client’s name. We sent cease-and-desist notices to the company, had those accounts disabled, and reconvened when it happened again.
Why Hiring the Right Lawyer Makes All the Difference?
Trademark disputes require speed and precision. A specialized lawyer can:
- File and oppose trademark applications.
- Draft strong cease-and-desist notices.
- Secure urgent injunctions within weeks.
- Represent clients in High Courts with technical expertise.
Advice from practice: Companies that involve lawyers in their business activities before the situation escalates, spend significantly less than those who wait until the damage is done.
Conclusion: Protect Your Brand Before It’s Too Late
Trademarks in India are strongly protected, but the strong protection is meaningless unless action is taken quickly. While courts will uphold rights in respect of a brand, waiting can result in a loss of company reputation and revenue.
From experience, businesses that registered and enforced their trademarks and brand rights at an early stage were confident in their growth, while others who did not, were entangled in legal battles that cost long periods of time, money and energy. The conclusion, is to protect your brand before someone else does.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. What is the difference between trademark infringement and passing off?
Trademark infringement applies to the trademark that has been registered and is then enforced under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Passing off would apply to unregistered trademarks and would be enforced primarily based on goodwill and reputation.
2. How long does it take to get an injunction in a trademark case?
If the infringement is strong, Indian courts are capable of providing an interim injunction within 2-4 weeks, while a full injunction and trial may take longer.
3. Do small businesses and startups really need trademark registration?
Yes. Many startups face copycat issues on e-commerce and social media. Registration makes enforcement easier and reduces litigation costs.
Talk to a Lawyer