When you apply for a foreign visa, it is common to incur several costs related to consultation, documents, filing, and others. Sometimes an agent can accept the payment but fail to submit the application, be too slow in processing the application, give incorrect assurances, or deny a refund. It may be necessary to look into the particularities of the situation that exists.
Why Visa Agent Disputes Arise
The visa-related disputes occur because the applicants rely upon the verbal assurances instead of the properly documented agreements.
Some of the common situations include:
- The agent accepts money but does not submit the visa application;
- The agent claims that the application has been filed but provides no application number;
- The agent delays filing the application without reasonable explanation;
- The agent promises a guaranteed visa;
- The agent collects government fees but does not deposit them;
- The agent stops communicating after receiving payment;
- The agent refuses to provide a refund;
- The agent deducts excessive or unexplained charges;
- The agent provides false information regarding the status of the application; or
- The agent misrepresents the visa category or immigration process.
Applicants should understand that payment of money does not automatically establish that a visa application has been filed.
The applicant should obtain the documentary proof of submission wherever it is applicable.
What Does It Mean When an Agent Takes Money but Does Not File the Visa?
If at all the applicant has paid the visa agent for filing visa application and the agent fails to mainly perform that agreed service, then the applicant may have grounds to seek for the refund or compensation, depending upon agreement and circumstances.
Assuming, for instance, an applicant pays ₹1,50,000 to a visa consultancy for a specific visa application. According to the contract, the consultancy must compile and send the application after collecting the necessary documents and payments.
In the case that the applicant provides all necessary documents and the consultancy gets the payment but fails to submit the visa application, the applicant can request:
- Refund of the amount for services not provided;
- Refund of any government or processing charges that were collected but not actually paid;
- Compensation where legally justified;
- Reimbursement of documented losses, where recoverable; and
- Appropriate legal costs, where awarded by the competent forum.
The precise amount recoverable will depend upon the contract, payments made, services actually rendered and applicable law.
Is the Visa Agent Legally Responsible?
A visa agent or immigration consultant may have contractual obligations towards the client.
If the agent has agreed to perform particular services for consideration and fails to perform them, the applicant may have a contractual dispute.
There may also be a consumer dispute where the arrangement falls within the scope of applicable consumer law and the applicant qualifies as a consumer.
However, every failed visa transaction is not automatically a criminal offence.
For example, an agent failing to complete work because of genuine administrative difficulties may involve a contractual or consumer dispute rather than cheating.
On the other hand, if there is evidence that the agent intentionally obtained money through false representations or dishonest conduct from the beginning, the facts may potentially warrant a criminal complaint under the applicable criminal law.
Therefore, the distinction between mere breach of contract and dishonest inducement can be important.
Documents and Evidence You Should Preserve
Before taking legal action, the applicant should preserve all available evidence. Important documents may include:
- Consultancy agreement;
- Service agreement;
- Invoice;
- Payment receipts;
- Bank statements;
- UPI transaction records;
- Credit/debit card statements;
- WhatsApp conversations;
- Emails;
- SMS messages;
- Advertisements published by the agent;
- Brochures or written promises;
- Copies of submitted documents;
- Passport submission receipts;
- Application forms;
- Appointment records;
- Application reference numbers;
- Receipts for government fees;
- Screenshots of online communications; and
- Audio or other evidence where lawfully obtained.
It is particularly important to preserve messages in which the agent acknowledges receiving money or promises to file the visa.
Do not delete conversations merely because the agent has stopped responding.
How to Demand Your Money Back
The applicant need to initially make clear written demand for the refund.
The communication should preferably mention:
- Date of engagement;
- Amount paid;
- Purpose for which payment was made;
- Services promised by the agent;
- Failure to provide the promised service;
- Date on which the application was expected to be filed;
- Previous requests made by the applicant;
- Amount sought to be refunded; and
- Reasonable time for making the refund.
The written communication is preferable because it mostly creates a documentary record.
The applicant should then avoid making any unsupported allegations or threats. The demand should mostly remain factual and clearly explain grievance.
Sending a Legal Notice to the Visa Agent
If at all the agent fails to respond to any repeated requests, the applicant may consider for sending the formal legal notice through advocate. A legal notice may:
- Identify the contractual relationship;
- Record the amount paid;
- Describe the services promised;
- Explain the failure to perform;
- Demand refund;
- Demand reimbursement of legally recoverable expenses or losses;
- Provide a specified period for compliance; and
- State that appropriate legal proceedings may be initiated if the demand is not complied with.
A legal notice often provides an opportunity to resolve the dispute before commencing formal proceedings.
It also creates the written record that applicant demanded for performance or refund.
Filing a Consumer Complaint
Where the transaction falls within the scope of consumer law, the applicant may consider approaching the appropriate Consumer Commission for deficiency in service or other legally recognized consumer grievance.
A complaint may be considered where the visa consultancy was engaged for consideration and the promised service was not properly provided.
Depending upon the facts, the applicant may seek appropriate relief such as:
- Refund of the amount paid;
- Compensation for proven loss or inconvenience;
- Litigation expenses; and
- Other relief permitted by the applicable consumer law.
However, the maintainability of a consumer complaint depends upon the specific facts, nature of the service, purpose for which it was obtained and applicable legal provisions.
Therefore, the applicant should examine the agreement and circumstances before selecting this remedy.
Police Complaint in Appropriate Cases
If at all the available evidence indicates the deliberate deception, dishonest inducement, forgery, misappropriation or any other cognizable offence, then the applicant may approach police with a complaint.
The complaint needs to contain factual details such as:
- Identity and address of the agent;
- Date of engagement;
- Amount paid;
- Mode of payment;
- Representations made by the agent;
- Documents provided to the agent;
- Promised services;
- Failure to provide the services;
- Subsequent communications;
- Evidence showing false representations, if any; and
- Financial loss suffered.
The applicant should attach copies of relevant documents and retain proof of submission of the complaint.
A criminal complaint should not be used merely as pressure for recovery where the facts disclose only a contractual disagreement. The nature of the conduct and available evidence should be carefully examined.
Civil Suit for Recovery of Money
A civil remedy may also be available for recovery of money depending upon the contractual relationship and applicable limitation provisions.
A civil proceeding may become relevant where:
- The amount involved is substantial;
- There is a clear contractual obligation;
- The agent refuses to refund;
- The dispute cannot be resolved through correspondence; or
- Any other available remedies are inadequate or is unsuitable.
Before initiating civil proceedings, it is important for the applicant to consult an attorney to clarify various questions pertaining to jurisdiction, the limitation period of the claim, court fees, drafting of the pleadings, and the type of relief sought by him/her.
In some cases, the sending of a legally worded notice can lead to the settlement of the case without recourse to judicial proceedings.
Can You Recover the Government Visa Fee?
This depends upon whether the amount was actually paid to the relevant authority.
For example, if the agent collected ₹30,000 claiming that it included a government application fee but never submitted the application or paid the fee, the applicant may have grounds to demand return of the amount that was collected for that purpose.
However, if the application was actually filed and the government fee was legitimately paid, that fee may be subject to the refund rules of the relevant foreign government or visa authority.
Therefore, applicants should distinguish between:
- Professional consultancy fees;
- Government application fees;
- Biometric fees;
- Appointment fees;
- Translation charges;
- Courier charges; and
- Other third-party expenses.
The agent should then ideally provide the proper receipts or documentary proof for the amounts claimed to have been paid to the third parties.
What If the Agent Claims That the Money Was Non-Refundable?
The clause describing the payment as the “non-refundable” does not necessarily end the matter in each and every situation. The applicant should examine:
- The exact wording of the agreement;
- The service actually provided;
- Whether the agent performed the promised obligations;
- Whether the non-refundable condition was properly disclosed;
- Whether the amount represents actual services or expenses;
- Whether any third-party fee was genuinely paid; and
- Whether the conduct of the agent involved misleading representations.
For example, there may be a substantial difference between an agent retaining a clearly agreed professional fee after performing significant work and an agent retaining the entire amount despite performing no promised service.
The enforceability and the effect of the contractual terms depend upon the applicable law and the facts of the case.
What If the Agent Has Disappeared or Stopped Responding?
If at all an agent stops responding after receiving the money, then the applicant should not simply continue waiting indefinitely.
The applicant should:
- Preserve all communication records;
- Verify the agent’s registered business details, where available;
- Collect proof of payment;
- Send a formal written demand;
- Issue a legal notice where appropriate;
- Consider a consumer proceeding where maintainable;
- Approach the police where the facts disclose a possible criminal offence; and
- Consider civil recovery proceedings where appropriate.
If most of the applicants have experienced the similar conduct by same agent, each affected person should then preserve their own documents and then consider obtaining the independent legal advice.
Practical Steps to Recover Your Money
Applicants dealing with a visa agent dispute should consider the following steps:
1. Stop making further payments
Do not make additional payments merely because the agent promises that the application will be filed later.
2. Ask for proof of filing
Request the application reference number, official acknowledgement, payment receipt or other documentary evidence showing that the application was actually submitted.
3. Collect payment evidence
Download bank statements, UPI records and payment receipts.
4. Preserve communications
Keep WhatsApp chats, emails and other relevant communications.
5. Review the agreement
Check the refund, cancellation and service clauses carefully.
6. Send a written refund demand
Clearly state the amount demanded and provide a reasonable deadline.
7. Consider a legal notice
If the agent does not cooperate, consult an advocate regarding a legal notice.
8. Choose the appropriate legal remedy
Depending upon the circumstances, this may include a consumer complaint, police complaint, civil recovery proceeding or other appropriate remedy.
9. Verify the visa status independently
Wherever possible, contact relevant embassy, consulate or official visa application centre through all of its official channels rather than relying exclusively on the information supplied by the agent.
10. Keep records of all expenses
Maintain evidence of additional expenses caused by the agent’s failure, because recovery of such amounts depends upon applicable law and proof.
Conclusion
Paying a visa agent does not guarantee that the application has been filed. If the agent fails to provide the promised service, applicants should preserve all evidence and demand a refund in writing. Depending on the circumstances, legal remedies may include a legal notice, consumer complaint, civil recovery action, or police complaint. Applicants should independently verify visa submission through official channels.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. Can I recover all of my money if at all the visa agent took payment but never filed my application?
Yes, recovery may be possible depending upon the agreement, payment records, services promised and circumstances of the case. You may then consider making the written refund demand and, wherever appropriate, pursuing the consumer, civil or any other legal remedies.
2. Can I file the police complaint against the visa agent?
The police complaint may be only appropriate where facts and evidence indicate the possible cheating, forgery, misappropriation or any other criminal offence. The mere contractual dispute does not automatically constitute any criminal offence.
3. What evidence should I keep against the visa agent?
Keep the agreement, receipts, bank or UPI records, WhatsApp conversations, emails, advertisements, documents submitted to the agent and any evidence showing representations made by the agent.
4. Can I send a legal notice to the visa agent?
Yes. A legal notice can formally record your grievance and demand refund or other appropriate relief within a specified period.
5. Can I approach the Consumer Commission against a visa consultancy?
Depending on the nature of the transaction and applicable law, a consumer complaint may be available for deficiency in service or other recognized consumer grievances. The specific facts should be examined before filing.
Talk to a Lawyer