When the homebuyer faces the delay in possession of the property, the question is: “Can the builder legally keep my money and delay the possession of the flat for years?”
This confusion is very much in common.
Understanding as to what rights the homebuyers have, what are the legal remedies that are available, as well as when the legal action should be taken that can help the buyers protect their financial interests as well as avoid the prolonged disputes.
What Builder Delay in Possession Really Means
After purchasing Real Estate Property typically, Buyers receive an allotment letter from the builder and then an agreement with the builder-Buyer from the builder.
The builder-buyer agreement typically includes various pieces of information, such as price, payment schedule, estimated possession date, and milestones of progress being made in relation to the construction.
As long as the Buyer continues to make a payment to the builder per the builder-buyer agreement, the builder is then legally bound to complete the project and give possession to the Buyer by the time stated in the agreement.
Construction delays could occur because of many legitimate reasons, including delayed government approvals needed to complete construction, labour shortages, or unforeseeable issues. If the builder has collected significant amounts from the Buyers and has either stopped all work or has experienced delays past a certain point, this would be a sufficient reason for the Buyer to pursue legal recourse against the builder for breach of contract and/or for inadequate service performance or unfair trade practices.
The Indian courts have consistently ruled that no Buyer can be required to wait indefinitely for possession of his/her property once payment has been made.
Why Builder Possession Delays Have Become a Major Issue
The last 10 years have seen home buyers throughout India experience very different financial hardships than what they would normally be able to afford due to delayed completion or occupancy by the builder of the property. Many buyers have paid nearly full price for their home and still had to wait several years until possession.
The impact of these delays can be both financial and non-financial in nature, as homebuyers will have housing loan EMIs to pay while also having to pay rent or lease for where they are living. In addition to this, families will have based their financial decisions concerning the purchase of a property based on when the builder was to deliver possession, and therefore will experience a considerable amount of financial stress from the delays.
In many cases, builders are unable to apply buyer payments towards the purchase of their homes because the builder has used funds collected from the buyers for other purposes, projects, or due to financial mismanagement, and have stopped the builder from completing the project. When those circumstances occur, home buyers typically need to seek out legal remedies to preserve their rights.
Legal Protection Available to Homebuyers in India
Homebuyers are protected very well through various legal means for claims against builders for delaying possession of their property. These include refunds, compensation, and the right to be given the possession of the property.
The real estate Regulatory and Development Act (RERA) 2016, The Consumer Protection Act 2019, civil suits for breach of contract (common law) and criminal fraud claims can all be pursued by the buyer against a builder if the buyer wants relief for the builder’s delay in providing the possession of the property.
These protections meant that builders cannot continue to keep buyers’ money without giving the buyers the property they purchased.
Legal Remedy Under the Real Estate Regulation and Development Act
The RERA Act was introduced in 2016 to provide a framework for the real estate industry and protect buyers from abusive practices.
One important feature of the Act is that it requires builders to register their projects with an appropriate authority before they can advertise or sell units. In addition, there are various requirements regarding how builders must keep buyers informed about project timelines, approvals, and progress on construction.
Section 18 of the Act gives buyers the right to withdraw from a project and receive a full refund plus interest if possession is not provided by the builder within certain timeframes. On the other hand, buyers have the option to remain in a project and receive compensation for delays.
The authorities that oversee the RERA Act can either order builders to refund money, penalize them for violations of the law or require them to complete projects that have stalled.
Consumer Court Remedies for Delayed Possession
Homebuyers also have the option of approaching consumer courts under the Consumer Protection Act 2019. In consumer law, a homebuyer is treated as a consumer because they purchase property for personal use and the builder provides construction services.
When a construction company does not provide you with what they promised to give you after paying them, then that is a failure of service. Consumer courts have the power to order builders to return any money that has been paid; pay interest on any money deposited; compensate you for the stress caused to you by the contractor; and pay for the legal costs of the case.
Consumer courts throughout India have consistently supported purchasers in disputes over delayed possession. Consumer courts have held that the builder is obligated to fulfil their contract with the buyer; the builder is not allowed to impose unreasonable terms or conditions on the buyer.
Civil Suit for Breach of Contract Against Builder
In addition to RERA and other remedies available to consumers, you can also initiate a civil suit against the builder for breach of contract. The builder buyer agreement is a legally binding contract and failure to deliver possession on schedule is considered to be a breach of that contract.
In either case, you can be awarded specific performance which would require the builder to deliver possession or you could be awarded a refund of your payment for failure to deliver possession as well as damages for the delay.
Civil courts can also grant interim relief under the Code of Civil Procedure until your case is resolved in order to protect your rights as a buyer.
Civil proceedings typically take longer than proceedings before either RERA or consumer courts; therefore, most buyers prefer those avenues.
Criminal Action Against Builders in Fraud Cases
There are cases where a builder’s actions appear to be fraudulent rather than just an extension in time for delivery of the home. If the builder collected funds from buyers without true intention of completing the project, he or she may have exposed him/herself to criminal liability.
Home purchasers can lodge criminal complaints against builders for offences that include cheating, criminal breach of trust, or conspiracy, under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
Criminal charges are usually initiated when evidence demonstrates that the builder intentionally deceived purchasers, misrepresented the particulars of the project, or diverted moneys intended for the construction to other uses.
Although not all delayed possession buyers will pursue a criminal case, there are instances of fraud where pursuing a criminal remedy would be appropriate and successful.
Important Supreme Court Judgments Protecting Homebuyers
Indian courts have repeatedly stated that home buyers should not have to suffer long periods of delay due to unfair actions taken by builders.
- When a builder has drafted a one-sided agreement that would create a binding obligation on a homebuyer, a precedent-setting decision was made by the Supreme Court in the case of Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Limited v. Govindan Raghavan in 2019. The purchaser can claim their deposit plus interest if there has been a delay of a reasonable period to obtain possession of the purchased property.
- In a case called Fortune Infrastructure Ltd. v. Trevor d’lima (2018), the Supreme Court ruled that when a developer cannot deliver possession of the property after a period of time that is reasonable under the circumstances, the developer has no basis in law or equity to require a buyer to wait indefinitely for completion of the purchase.
- Another important decision is found in the case of Kolkata West International City Pvt Limited v. Devasis Rudra (2019). The Supreme Court declared that if a buyer has not received possession of the property after an extended period, this will constitute a failure in the provision of service and will allow the buyer to withdraw from the purchase contract and return the buyer’s initial deposit plus interest.
Judgments such as those listed above have greatly enhanced the legal rights of homebuyers throughout India.
Documents Required to File a Case Against a Builder
If a purchaser chooses to proceed with a lawsuit, there are some important pieces of documentation that will be helpful in supporting the claim.
These typically include the builder buyer agreement (also known as “the allotment letter”), payment receipts (such as copies of checks) or bank statements indicating payments made towards the purchase of the property, bank loan documents if financing for the purchase of the property was secured, project brochures or advertisements that were published by the builder, and any correspondence (via email, letter or otherwise) between the buyer and builder concerning the buyer’s rights to possession.
This documentation will assist in proving those payments made by the buyer and also show that the builder did not provide possession of the property to the buyer within the time frame set out in the agreement.
Practical Steps Homebuyers Should Take
Before initiating all of the legal proceedings, the buyers need to take certain practical steps to strengthen their case.
- Sending the legal notice to the builder by demanding the possession or refund is often the first step. The notice needs to formally record the buyer’s grievance and it may sometimes lead to the resolution without litigation.
- Another practical step that a buyer should take is confirming that the real estate project is registered with their local Real Estate Registration Authority, and obtaining copies of any and all documentation pertaining to the real estate property purchase.
- Consulting with a real estate attorney will be helpful in determining what would be the most appropriate legal remedy based on the particular facts surrounding each case.
What You Should Practically Do Right Now
If you are facing a delay in possession of your property:
- Do not keep waiting indefinitely without legal advice
- Preserve all documents and payment records carefully
- Send a legal notice to the builder if possession is delayed significantly
- Check whether the project is registered under RERA
- Consult the lawyer to evaluate best legal remedy available
Taking the timely action often increases chances of obtaining relief through the legal proceedings.
How We Help Homebuyers in Builder Delay Cases
We help homebuyers assess their legal rights; analyse builder-buyer agreements; create legal notices; and ultimately file cases before RERA authorities, consumer courts, or civil courts based on their unique situations.
Essentially, we want to help homebuyers either get possession of their properties within a reasonable time or obtain refunds with compensation for the delays suffered prior to possession.
One can talk to lawyer from Lead India for any kind of legal support. In India, free legal advice online can be obtained at Lead India. Along with receiving free legal advice online, one can also ask questions to the experts online free through Lead India.
FAQs
1. Can a builder legally delay possession for many years?
No. Builders cannot indefinitely delay possession after taking money from buyers.
2. Can I get a refund if the builder delays possession?
Yes. Under RERA and consumer law, buyers can seek refund along with interest.
3. Which is better for the delayed possession, the RERA or the consumer court?
Both of the forums provide effective remedies. The appropriate option mostly depends on facts of the case.
4. Can criminal action be taken against the builder?
Yes, if at all the delay involves fraud, cheating, or misrepresentation.
5. How long does it take to resolve the builder delay case?
The timeline mostly depends on the forum, but the RERA cases are generally resolved faster than the civil suits.
Talk to a Lawyer