Is it valid to give rent to a non-heir relative?

Is it valid to give property rent to a stranger or someone related, and deny it to a legal heir in the absence of any will? My brother is not giving me half of the rent but is giving it to my aunt, saying that this was our father's wish. It seems he is benefiting from it. What should be my argument in a partition suit to recover that money? How do I recover the 50% money being transferred to my aunt, who is not a legal heir while my brother and I are the legal heirs? How can I stop the rent being taken by my brother or aunt until the court decides the case? Does this argument hold in court if they say our father’s oral wish was to give 50% of the rent to our aunt (whom we haven’t met in the last 20 years)? He also claims that he has spent the rent money on property maintenance for the last 10 years since the case was filed in court. Is this maintainable in court?

1 Answer
Only verified advocates can give an answer Sign In
Admin
Advocate By LEAD INDIA Answered: 04 Mar 2025

If there is no will, the rent should be divided equally between the legal heirs. You can file a partition suit in court to claim your rightful share. You can also seek an injunction to stop your brother or aunt from taking the rent until the court decides. The argument about your father’s oral wish may not hold strong without proof. For further legal assistance contact us on our helpline number.
 

24x7 Help

If we fall short of your expectation in any way, let us know

Payment Trust

All refunds come with no questions asked guarantee

Talk to Lawyer

Talk Now